Crooked Stick
Established homes surrounding Crooked Stick Golf Club, the Pete Dye-designed private club that has hosted major championships.
Crooked Stick is one of the higher-priced neighborhoods in Carmel, with a median sale price of $1.85M, about 144% above the Carmel median in this data. Demand is strong, with a median of 4 days on market and a median sale-to-list price of 97.9%. Recent sales feature private pools in 67% of recent sales, basements in most homes, larger lots, around 1.3 acres at the median.
By median sale price, Crooked Stick ranks 3 of the 108 Carmel neighborhoods in this guide, among the most expensive for the area. Buyers pay a premium per square foot here: about $298 against a typical $185 across Carmel neighborhoods, which usually points to location, lot or finish quality rather than sheer size.
Crooked Stick by the numbers.
9 of 9 recent sales here were $750K or more, making Crooked Stick one of the stronger luxury markets in Carmel.
Based on information from the Broker Listing Cooperative® (BLC®), Nov 2025 to Oct 2026, for sales over $500K only, so figures describe the upper part of the market rather than every sale. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
What you'll find in Crooked Stick.
The typical recent sale was 5,019 square feet with 5 bedrooms on about 1.3 acres. Homes were built between 1969 and 2020. Nearly every home has a basement; 67% of recent sales had a pool.
Every home is different, and the right price depends on the details. I'll prepare a valuation built from the closest recent sales to yours.
- Typical size
- 5,019 sq ft
- Bedrooms
- 5 (median)
- Built
- 1969–2020
- Lot size
- 1.30 acres (median)
- School district
- Carmel Clay Schools
- City
- Carmel
What matters when you sell here.
The homes that sold quickest and closest to asking were priced from the nearest comparable sales and presented well from the first day; the ones that lingered usually started too high.
At this price level the buyer pool is smaller and more specific, so marketing goes beyond the MLS: targeted exposure to relocation buyers, agents who work the $750K+ market, and photography that does the home justice.
Golf-course frontage, views and club membership terms each move value here, and they need to be documented and marketed, not just mentioned.
Larger lots bring questions about septic, wells, outbuildings and future splits; answering them in the listing keeps buyers from discounting for uncertainty.
I live in Indianapolis and work these neighborhoods every week. More about selling in Carmel, or compare a cash offer if you need to sell fast.
Find out what your Crooked Stick home would sell for.
A custom valuation, prepared, reviewed and refined by me personally, based on recent Crooked Stick sales. Need to sell fast? I can include a cash offer to compare.
Nearby price points in Carmel.
Crooked Stick real estate FAQ.
What is the median home price in Crooked Stick?
Among 9 recent sales over $500K in Crooked Stick (Nov 2025 to Oct 2026), the median sale price was $1.85M, ranging from $760K to $4.6M.
How fast do homes sell in Crooked Stick?
The median home sold in 4 days on market, at a median of 97.9% of its final list price.
What school district serves Crooked Stick?
Most recent sales in Crooked Stick were in Carmel Clay Schools. Always confirm school assignment for a specific address.
What is the price per square foot in Crooked Stick?
About $298 per square foot at the median for recent sales, compared with a typical $185 across Carmel neighborhoods in this guide. Finished basements, lot and condition move individual homes well above or below that figure.
Is Crooked Stick a luxury market?
9 of the 9 recent sales in Crooked Stick closed at $750,000 or more, so most of the market here is at the luxury level.
How do I find out what my Crooked Stick home is worth?
Request a free valuation and I will build it personally from the closest recent Crooked Stick sales, adjusted for your home's size, condition, updates and lot, rather than a citywide average or an online estimate. There is no obligation.